It’s that time of year again: The sun sets earlier, there is a wee nip of fall in the air, the divine smell of roasting chilies is everywhere, I am beginning to get sick of fresh veggies, and a deep melancholy is winding it’s way to the surface of my heart. Why does it surprise me year after year? I am happily busy with farm chores, family trips, visitors, daily life… and then my feet start to drag and I find myself turning inward. Yes, it’s that time of year again… time to light the candle, time to remember difficult memories. 6 yrs ago today, on August 28th, 2005, our son Rowan was born… and died. Or perhaps I should rephrase: He died and was born.
Rowan Cecil Scott Roch was 20 inches long and weighed 7 lbs 11 oz. He had wavy ginger hair. He looked like his namesake – his great grandmother Cecil. His eyes never gazed into mine and his lungs never knew the shock of the first inhalation of our atmosphere. He was beautiful, perfect, and dead.
Our last prenatal appointment was on a Tues and he was very active with a strong heartbeat, ready to take on birth and life. My due date was 4 days later – on a Saturday – and like clockwork, my contractions began in earnest, exactly on time. Birth bag was packed, car seat strapped in awaiting his little body, and we drove to the birth center, nervous and very, very excited to meet our son after a natural water birth. But the midwife could find no heartbeat. I didn’t worry for a second. Truly. It was all too right. My pregnancy had been picture-perfect, I had taken my pre-natals and fish oil, done my pre-natal yoga, meditated and talked to our son, had (reluctantly) one ultrasound at 25 wks, taken long walks while describing to our baby the beauties of the stark, windswept mesa we lived on. I had faith and I had trust… back then. The hospital nurse ran the ultrasound wand over my bursting belly again and again in silence. The midwives were silent. Randy was silent. The entire world seemed to hold it’s breath. “I am sorry Ms. Scott. There is no heartbeat. Your baby is dead.”
Time screeched to a halt. No one moved. I heard the blood rushing in my ears, pounding along with my racing heart, beating fiercely enough for both of us. Disbelief. Anger. But not grief – not yet. I slammed the door on my grief and my eyes remained dry. Some other part of my personality pulled out my “take charge” hat and slapped it firmly on my head, pushing back the panic, the collapse, the puddle on the floor I so badly wanted to be. “Are you sure?” Was that really my voice? I sounded so far away… so not like myself… so harsh… so stern. “Yes.” the nurse confirmed. “I am so very sorry.” I cleared my throat. “Well,” I said in the distant stranger’s voice, “I guess I don’t need a natural birth anymore as that was for my baby. Let’s get this over with then. I want an epidural and a C-section. Let’s do it.” Christ! Who WAS this woman talking? How could she be so cold and calculated?
It was 30 minutes before the anesthesiologist came to the room. My contractions continued. I told Randy to call my support person, Joanne, and tell her she didn’t need to come. I was all steel, teeth clenched. The anesthesiologist returned again after an additional 30 minutes to inform me he could not give me any form of anesthesia due to the types of supplements I had been taking. There was a chance my blood would not clot and I could bleed internally. Too risky. Joanne burst in, face stained with tears, and marched to my bed. “Not coming my ass! Fuck that!” Some how I found the ability to laugh – only she could have gotten away with that maneuver. My labor lasted 12 hrs, my heart numb and my body wracked with pain. My sole job was to keep my shit together and push away the stinkin’ elephant in the room: You are going through all this pain and suffering for nothing! Your baby is DEAD.
On the morning after my due date, with an unbelievable rush of pain, Rowan’s body sloshed out into the waiting hands of our loving midwife. I was cynically aware the doctor had let her catch – after all, there was no liability issue with an already dead baby. I closed my eyes in utter relief and drifted into a dark silence, so akin to the world he had just come from. After what seemed like eternity, there was a nudge against my arm, bringing me back to my exquisite pain. I opened my eyes upon Randy’s tear-stained face. In his arms was a little blanketed bundle. How could this be happening? Why were those long, strong limbs so still and white? Where was the newborn mewling? The thrashing, pink fists? I noticed then I was seeing the scene from above my body, void of emotion, watching the exhausted midwives, Joanne beside me, the nurse a discrete distant away, and Randy’s shoulders shaking in unchecked grief. I reached out instinctively for my son, cradled him tenderly, and set about examining every inch of his body with stoic remove. His tiny fingernails were stained with meconium. There was a crimson drop of blood resting just inside one nostril. His lips were the color of ripe cherries. His skin was white, waterlogged, wrinkled and blistered. I realized with a clinical eye that he had been dead for a few days and the lack of circulation had caused this. His wet hair was plastered against his head in light auburn waves. He was so very limp and heavy; It was hard to contain his drooping, flaccid appendages. My heart wrapped around him like a steel band of fierce protection. Laying on my side, both my body and soul in tremendous pain, I cuddled him tightly in my arms refusing to let go…. for a long time. The warmth he had borrowed from my womb slowly faded and his stiffening body became cold against me.
We were left alone to say our hello and goodbye to this tiny dream before us. I pushed away thoughts of our waiting home, so perfectly ready for him…. drawers filled with freshly laundered clothes, off-road stroller, baby packs and slings, stacks of cloth diapers and wool covers, everything organic, books, toys, and stuffed animals ready to greet him. We un-swaddled him together and bathed his blistered skin carefully – it was very fragile and tore so easily. He was as white as a porcelain doll. With characteristic practicality, I left him undiapered and undressed, merely re-swaddled in the blanket from the hospital. I knew his wrinkled body would first pass by the pathologist’s scalpel before burning to ashes in the crematorium. Why waste the organic cotton diapers and onsie, the wee matching hat and booties, still zipped tightly in my birth bag? We spent 4 hrs with our baby’s body, trying to remember every detail, every dimple, every lock of hair. We took dozens of pictures. We kissed his cold toes and fingers, his little nose so like my own. But I never had the courage to open his eyes. And then, against every bone in my body, we laid him on the bed, turned our backs, and walked slowly down the long corridor to our unexpected, new life and our waiting grief.
The midwives let us rest on a birth bed in their nurturing birth center. It had been over 24 hrs since we had slept and we had just survived the most difficult experience of our lives. Randy and I laid thankfully under the homemade quilt, wrapped in each other arms, our bodies completely empty and totally spent. And as the late summer rain began to fall outside the open windows, my heart released it’s iron control and the floodgates opened. I cried my first tears. And then I sobbed a river of grief for which there was no end.
And 6 yrs later I still cry. In fact, there is a pile of wadded tissues beside me as I type. Certainly the pain has subsided… changed. But it never leaves. It makes it more difficult that a cause was never found. Both Rowan and I underwent a battery of tests after his death, but nothing was uncovered – the mystery remains. Perhaps a wrapped cord? A clot in the cord? We will never know. People who have never lost a child make the assumption that a subsequent child will “make it all better”. They think the score card is settled, our grief erased, a baby for a baby. And, as parents who have lost a child know well, nothing could be further from the truth. Instead we feel the the absence of Isla’s big brother even more. There was suppose to be two! They should be growing up together, playing side by side, adventuring, loving, learning, experiencing life as siblings. When I first put Isla to my breast, her unfocused gray eyes searching my face, certainly I felt a great joy and a profound love. But I also remembered the feverish pain of my hot, swollen breasts, leaking colostrum that my son would never taste. At each developmental step Isla reaches, I realize more fully what we have missed with Rowan. I still have dreams about finding a little boy with red hair, adopting a little boy, rescuing a little boy. These dreams seem to increase around his birthday and around the holidays – the times for family celebration and togetherness, the times when I feel the hole in my heart the most.
It was a huge step in my healing process to purge our lives of all the baby things that Isla could no longer use. Even though Randy had a vasectomy several months after Isla’s birth, I still clung to the fantasy that I would miraculously get pregnant again, or our foster/adoption counselor would make that long awaited call to us. I believe I have fully accepted, finally, that Isla will be an only child, and even feel contentment in that acceptance. At the ripe age of 49, I am truly happy to be done with the newborn combat zone. But then Rowan’s birthday sneaks up on me and I find my mind full of fantasies of little red-headed boys once more.
It’s that time of year again.
And we miss you so much my son.
Maclaren,
Thank you so much for sharing your story. It is profoundly important and deeply touching. You are such a brave and heroic mama to have flourished so completely as a result of your experiences. You have become an incredible mother! I know that Rowan will always be a part of your family in such a huge way, how could he not be?I love you and will light a candle this morning in memory of Rowan and in celebration of your family. Please reach out if you need anything at all. With Love
As I read this incredible story, I was overcome by such emotion. When this occurred, I didn’t know either of you. Jay had mentioned the sad incident to Dave at Pilar; I was working at Xache along with Chris Pieper who mentioned the story in very general terms to his class. He was concerned about his good friends undergoing such grief. I asked him, “you are talking about Randy Roch, aren’t you?’ I, too, felt sadness for you.
Now I know you, work with you. I had no idea how intense a loss like this can be. Reading your story certainly impacted my thoughts and my heart. No doubt, his memory will always be strong in both your hearts.
Thank you for sharing this. It meant a lot to me, just as you both do.
Affectionately,
Beverlee Gard
This post leaves me with tears streaming down my face. It is beautifully and poignantly written. I love you both! Kiersten
Thank you Bev, Jillie and Kiersten for your kind and loving words. It is scary writing about something so tragic in a public venue and I appreciate your support. We are so lucky to have you all in our lives. XO
Your post brought tears to my eyes. I am so sorry for your loss. Thank you for your courage in sharing your story.
Thank you for writing Rebecca. It means a lot to know people are reading. π
Hi MacLaren,
I’m so glad you wrote your tragic story. Life can be difficult in the extreme and deeply painful experiences can be relived for years. Acceptance of that fact can lead to peace of mind, and even, deeper appreciate of our time here.
You lived to witness another story and I hope you will write that story next.
Take care,
Seamus
PS: I did not know you could write so well. Beautiful!
Thanks Seamus. It’s been a very therapeutic exercise to write Rowan’s story and share it publicly. XO
thank you for sharing your strength, sadness, grief and yearning wonder. i appreciate the layers of your healing and insights as a mama, and that perhaps only mamas and papas could fathom… many blessings to you, randy, isla and rowan. xo – dawn
Thanks for your loving words Dawn. We are so blessed to have you and Henry in our lives! Sharing our story on my blog has really reminded me what an incredible community we are surrounded by. XO
I am sobbing with you, but looking forward to seeing Isla in five or six weeks even more, if that is possible.
We love you, Dad
We love you too Dad! See you in Oct for sure! XOXO
Dear MacLaren and Randy,
So much pain you have both endured! I am so sorry for the loss of your son. You have expressed beautiful memories of him and I hope that they will carry you through.
Fondly,
Donna Figurski (Kiersten’s mom)
Thank you so much Donna. I hope we will see you some time this year! XO
I am in awe of how beautifully you write! You are an amazing woman MacLaren and I love you. Happy Birthday little Rowan. There is a huge void in our lives without you.
Thank you Katherine. We will bring the family over soon to do some canoeing with you. Love to you and the gang! XO
MacLaren, Randy, and Isla: We love you all so much, even without ever meeting you MacLaren, or you Isla, so of course we also love Rowan even without ever meeting him. Since our anniversary is so close to Rowans birth, we always think of him around that time. Please know that we are still saddened by this tragic event. Normally we would read the journal you wrote back then around now, but since we moved, I’m not sure which box it is in. I so appreciated this update. Your pain is real and everlasting, We are sending you all hugs that come staight from out heart.
You are so sweet Dar. Thank you for you love and support. Hope we will see you and Jerry this fall. XOXO MacLaren
maclaren, i’ve started to read this three or four times now and had to stop each time to allow myself some tears. beautifully, lovingly, and honestly written. love to you, randy, rowan, and isla.
Thank you Mattie. Much love to you too dear. XO
oh Mama…i have fallen off your blog in this final week of my trip to the moon and back…and just checked in and have been frozen in front of the screen, sort of trying not to let the emotions overcome me the way they are. i feel Rowan and your and Randy’s and Isla’s love and loss of him as this flush of tingling warmth throughout me. tears. and i just feel ‘off’. i love you so much and i will always love hearing any stories of Rowan you ever want to tell me. i’ve cherished every one before now, too. thank you for being so strong and for sharing your moments with Rowan (and his spirit, since) you are such a beautiful mother and dear friend. you inspire the heck out of me. i love you 4 so much.
Thank you Jenny. I can’t truly express how much you mean to us and how much we have missed you this summer! You will always be the first one I share our Rowan stories with. π By the way, Isla has not seen him in the chandelier for a while – thought he’d make an appearance around his birthday… but maybe Christmas instead. XOXO
Oh, I feel that I am so late in sending you these words. I am just so touched by your beautiful account of Rowan. You are so brave to write these words, I love everything you say and how you say it. It makes me think about Isla looking up at the light.
Thank you for sharing. Some day I want to share this with Lachlan and Lilly. They are so curious about Rowan.
We love you so much.
And you my dear! You have always been one of my main support mamas Ang. β€
[…] I cried for the bouncing, playful kids that would never entertain us, and I cried for my son, Rowan, who we had lost at birth. I had remembered his warm, limp weight in my arms with each kid I laid […]